Member’s Area

the newsroom

The Best Email Marketing Strategies for Small Business Owners

WhatsApp Image 2025-03-26 at 09.00.58

Prefer Audio? Listen to the Podcast!

While social media platforms shift with every algorithm update, email remains a direct and high-converting marketing channel. With over 4 billion daily users and 60% of consumers making purchases from promotional emails, your email list can be a stable, scalable source of revenue. This guide reveals the tested strategies and tools that help real small businesses thrive with email.

1. The Undeniable Power of Email Marketing

Key Tips:
  • Email marketing boasts a 4,200% ROI (DMA study)
  • 60% of consumers say they’ve made a purchase due to a marketing email
  • Email automation boosts small business revenue by up to 30% (Salesforce)
Real-Life Example:
Birchbox, a beauty subscription box startup, grew to over 1 million subscribers in large part due to its personalized email campaigns. Their welcome series, product recommendations, and re-engagement flows were all driven by user behavior and consistently outperformed social channels in driving conversions.

2. 5 Essential Email Sequences for Small Businesses

1. The Welcome Series (3–5 Emails)

Key Tips:
  • Build trust, communicate value, and offer incentives
  • Sequence: brand story → top products → discount offer
Real-Life Example:
Harry’s, the men’s grooming brand, used a 5-email welcome sequence that led to a significant boost in conversion rates, according to their co-founder Jeff Raider in an interview with Forbes. Their first email focused on the brand story; the final email offered a discount.

2. Abandoned Cart Sequence

Key Tips:
  • Send the first email within 1 hour
  • Add urgency and testimonials in follow-ups
Real-Life Example:
Chubbies Shorts reported recovering over $250,000 in lost sales per year using a 3-part abandoned cart sequence with humor and urgency. Their emails included phrases like, “Your shorts are lonely” and used personalized product images.

3. Re-Engagement Campaign

Key Tips:
  • Subject lines like “We miss you + a gift” increase open rates
  • Offer value while allowing unsubscribes
Real-Life Example:
Grammarly used a re-engagement campaign titled, “Still writing?” to reactivate dormant users. The campaign led to a 45% increase in re-engagement and helped clean their list for better deliverability.

4. Post-Purchase Follow-Up

Key Tips:
  • Reinforce satisfaction and ask for reviews
  • Share product tips to reduce returns
Real-Life Example:
Glossier, the cosmetics brand, follows up every order with thank-you notes, how-to-use guides, and personalized product suggestions—contributing to their 60% repeat customer rate, as reported in Inc. Magazine.

5. Value-Driven Newsletter

Key Tips:
  • 80% educational/entertaining, 20% promotional
  • Keeps brand top-of-mind between purchases
Real-Life Example:
Morning Brew, a daily business newsletter, built a $75 million media brand with a newsletter that prioritizes value over sales. They monetize via sponsored content but maintain a loyal audience by focusing on high-value information

Proven Email Optimization Tactics

Key Tips:
  • Place your primary call-to-action in the P.S.—readership jumps 79%
  • Use subject lines that offer time-sensitive exclusivity
  • Best send times:
    • B2C: Tuesday or Thursday at 8–10 AM
    • B2B: Wednesday at 10 AM–12 PM
Real-Life Example:
Casper, the mattress company, once ran a “mistake” campaign (“Oops, we goofed”) offering 15% off. The email had a 3x higher conversion rate than their usual sales emails, as reported by their team at a Mailchimp conference.

Case Study: How a Local Bakery Hit $10K/Month via Email

Background:
  • Business: Whisked!, a small bakery based in Washington, D.C.
  • Strategy: Used “Free Cookie Friday” opt-in to build list
Implementation:
  • Sent weekly behind-the-scenes emails
  • Automated birthday discounts
  • Used Mailchimp for segmentation
Results:
  • 3,500+ subscribers in 6 months
  • Email drove 40% of total monthly revenue
  • Saved $5,000 in Facebook ad costs by shifting focus to email

Critical Email Mistakes to Avoid

  • Never buy email lists—it ruins deliverability
  • Limit frequency to 1–2 emails per week
  • Ensure emails are mobile-optimized—60% are opened on phones
  • Use a clear single CTA per message
  • Run A/B tests on subject lines regularly
Real-Life Example:
J.Crew once experienced a 20% drop in engagement due to over-sending daily emails. After cutting back and improving segmentation, their open rates rebounded, according to a Retail Dive report.

30-Day Email Marketing Implementation Plan

Week 1: Launch a welcome email sequence
Week 2: Build an abandoned cart flow
Week 3: Launch your first value-driven newsletter
Week 4: Analyze open/click rates and run an A/B test

Recommended Free Tools

  • MailerLite: Free up to 1,000 subscribers with automation features
  • Canva: Drag-and-drop designs for branded email graphics
  • SubjectLine.com: Analyze subject lines for deliverability and performance

Wrap-Up: Email Converts When You Work It Right

Your email list isn’t just a contact sheet—it’s your highest ROI asset. With the right sequences, optimization, and tools, even small businesses can drive big revenue. Start with just one sequence and build your system from there.
Next Step: Choose and launch one email sequence this week—start simple, and let results guide your next move.

💬 Let’s talk: 

What’s one small habit you’ll commit to today? 

Comment below—I’d love to hear!

Want More Habit-Building Tips

🔥 Want more habit-building tips? Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive insights!
Subscribe Now
Discuss this article in 'The Boardroom'